| POS | PLAYER | TEAM |
| QB | Jake Plummer | DEN |
| RB | Chester Taylor | BALT |
| RB | Priest Holmes | KC |
| RB | Willie Parker | PITT |
| RB | Jamal Lewis | BALT |
| WR | Roy Williams | DET |
| WR | Jimmy Smith | JAX |
| WR | Rod Smith | DEN |
| WR | Joe Jurevicious | SEA |
| WR | Antonio Bryant | CLE |
| TE | Chris Cooley | WASH |
| K | Sebastian Janikowski | OAK |
| K | Jeff Reed | PITT |
| D | Buffalo | BUFF |
| D | Jacksonville | JAX |
| D | Baltimore | BALT |
